(note sorry for the iphone not well staged photos.... I was so excited to share my new favorite modeling paste with you) I was in no way compensated for this review. I purchased the paste at EMI Scrapbooking store in Cumming GA for my personal use - I'm just a user sharing my opinions.
I've tried a lot of them & always come back to Golden brand.
I know Teresa really strives for quality in everything she does so I was excited to try her Basically Essential Modeling Paste.
Opening the jars to compare them I noticed that the Golden is much thicker than the Basically Essential which seems more creamy. Comparing the color Basically Essential is noticeably whiter as the Golden has more grey undertones.
I used a Teresa Collins Basically Essential stencil set. (This release contains 2 different 8-1/2x11 inch sets that contain 3 stencils & 2 12x12 inch single stencils) These are good quality intricately cut stencils & gotta love the pink color! By the way make sure you clean your stencils immediately - especially with modeling paste it can ruin them quickly.
I applied Basically Essential to a small section of the stencil. I noticed it was very creamy & glides on very smoothly. It's a little thinner than Golden brand so I was concerned that it would seep under the stencil a bit. Upon removing the stencil there was a small area top row second from right but it would be fine if I had taped the stencil down - I was just holding it. I was pleasantly surprised that it held so much of the texture from the pallet knife application since it was a thinner body paste. The paste levels out perfectly & holds sharp edges. It dries a nice uniform white that is perfect to use straight out of the jar on any project. The thinner consistency allows for some flexibility which is really beneficial on a scrapbook layout or mini book that will be viewed by turning pages.
I applied the Golden brand in the same manner. It is noticeably thicker & seems to have a measurably thicker emboss for each of the stencil openings. When applying it really fills the stencil opening well & as I did that final sweep across to even out & remove waste more of the paste seemed left in the stencil openings. I didn't stir my jar very well before application but you can slightly see the variance of color which has very grey areas especially viewing in person.
Most of the time I have added a paint or ink to the Golden modeling paste when I'm creating a project. So let's see how the Teresa Collens Basically Essential holds up to products I usually use.
First I like acrylic inks since they have a very intense color. Liquitex make some pretty colors. It mixed very well but the bright white color of the paste did act somewhat like white paint toning down the color of the ink.
The watery consistency of the ink did thin the paste somewhat but didn't effect the integrity of the paste to hold it's shape. The color dried true & even.
Next I tried my favorite Golden Fluid Acrylics. They are also a bit thinner consistency but the colors are very intense & mix well with many mediums & paints.
Again the paste & paint mixed very well. The paste acted slightly as a white paint toning down the color of the fluid acrylic. The paste still had the ability to hold it's shape & pallet knife texture lines. It did have a small amount of seeping under the stencil but again that was because I didn't tape it down. It seems like with the thinner paste I can't skip that step as easily as I can with a thicker paste. I really like the areas where I didn't have a lot of paste left & it created holes in the stencil negative.
Finally I used some Blick Artist Acrylic paint. It's a very thick creamy paint.
This thicker paint mixed very easily & thoroughly with the modeling paste. It made the paste a thicker consistency without losing the creaminess. I love all the texture lines that held & the uniform color.
You could easily just use craft acrylic paint & it would most likely be slightly thinner in texture but have same effects.
I'm most impressed with the color of Teresa Collins Basically Essential Modeling Paste when it is dry. The white is very clean & uniform. I have not seen this in any other modeling paste that I have tried in the past. Golden is on the bottom & you can see the color is not as vibrant & bright. I would use the Basically Essential modeling paste alone & be very pleased with the color of the dried application. I normally add white paint to the Golden paste to get the true bright white that comes straight out of the jar with Teresa's paste.
So let the trumpets sound........
Sorry Golden Modeling Paste but you have been dethroned as my favorite modeling paste..... I will be buying Teresa Collins Basically Essential Modeling Paste from now on. (If I want heavy texture I think I will still pull out the Golden but for overall usability I loved Teresa's paste)
Love the white color straight out of the jar dries beautifully, creamy consistency
self leveling so very even application in the stencil with sharp edges
bend ability without cracking
ability to mix well with different mediums.
Have to be mindful of seeping under stencil due to the thinner consistency
if texture is what you are looking for this paste can do some but since it seems to self level you don't get as much as you do with other brands of paste.
I encourage you to give Teresa's modeling paste a try it's perfect for paper crafters to try a new technique and add some texture & elegance to your page.